Irving Berlin's White Christmas Wraps Toby's Dinner Theatre in Holiday Cheer

Nov 22, 2026
Irving Berlin's White Christmas at Toby's Dinner Theatre - Columbia

Few holiday titles carry as much built-in affection as Irving Berlin's White Christmas, and the production now on stage at Toby's Dinner Theatre in Columbia is earning the kind of response that suggests the affection is well placed. The stage musical grows out of the 1954 film and packs in 17 Berlin songs, a handful of which never appeared on screen. There is an added note of occasion this year, too: Toby's is presenting its final Christmas show in its current building before moving into a new facility next spring.

The story remains as comfortable as a favorite sweater. Army buddies Bob Wallace and Phil Davis trail a sister act, Betty and Judy Haines, to a Vermont inn that turns out to belong to General Waverly, the commander they served under in World War II. Unseasonably warm December weather has kept both the snow and the paying guests away, so the two showmen hatch a plan to rescue the place with a big show and a reunion of their old company. A misunderstanding about Bob's motives sends Betty packing for a nightclub engagement in New York, and he has to go after her before the curtain can rise and the romance can right itself.

The cast is the production's greatest asset. Jeffrey Shankle and David James make a winning pair as Bob and Phil, with easy comic rapport and voices to match, and James in particular dazzles whenever the tap shoes come out. Janine Sunday and Rachel Cahoon blend beautifully as the Haines sisters and land the laughs in "Sisters," while Sunday's torch song, "Love, You Didn't Do Right By Me," stops the show. Robert Biedermann gives General Waverly both military starch and retired-man grumpiness, and his final scene is the emotional high point of the evening. Jane C. Boyle nearly walks away with the show as Martha, the housekeeper with a Broadway past and a Merman-sized belt, and Shawn Kettering juggles four roles, the best of them the laconic handyman Ezekiel.

The musical numbers arrive one after another like presents. "Blue Skies" closes the first act as a full-scale production number, and "I Love a Piano" opens the second with dancers tapping from their seats and atop a baby grand. "Snow" becomes a lovely four-part harmony piece, and "Happy Holiday/Let Yourself Go" brings down the house. Christen Svingos's choreography ranges across tap, ballet, jazz and modern styles and is at its best when the full ensemble fills the floor. Mark Minnick's direction makes smart use of the theatre's in-the-round layout and locates the real feeling underneath all the tinsel.

The design work completes the picture. A single playing space becomes a barracks, a train car, the inn, a barn and a Manhattan nightclub in turn, and when the barn doors finally swing open, snow is falling. The costumes are bright and witty, from bell skirts shaped like ornaments to the Santa-inspired finale outfits, and Ross Scott Rawlings leads a first-rate live orchestra that sets the mood from the overture on. A generous buffet comes with the ticket, along with a frozen hot chocolate specialty drink served in a souvenir glass.

Irving Berlin's White Christmas plays through January 10, 2027, at Toby's Dinner Theatre, 5900 Symphony Woods Road in Columbia.