Everything Is Wonderful Reviews

MetroWeekly- Somewhat Recommended

"...The fragmented narrative doesn't fit together with such satisfying sureness. Sticklin and his cast don't give us enough to stay oriented in the constant shifts between past and present, employing hints too faint for us to discern how much each respective character knows or doesn't know based on the chronology of when secrets are revealed. More confounding than intriguing, the play loses traction."

MD Theatre Guide- Highly Recommended

"...Just blocks from the Friday night-time activity in Dupont Circle, the Amish community is depicted in the DC premiere of “Everything Is Wonderful” at The Keegan Theatre. How lovely to sit in the cozy, intimate theatre and ponder on the theme of Chelsea Marcantel’s play: How to forgive and be forgiven."

DC Theater Arts- Highly Recommended

"...Keegan Theatre is offering a cautionary tale about how fraught this process is, with a quietly powerful offering of Chelsea Marcantel’s Everything Is Wonderful at their Church Street theater through October 5. The play had been previously staged five years earlier at Baltimore’s Everyman Theatre, but this is the DC premiere."